A central concept in United States employment law is that employment is ‘at will’. This means that, in the absence of a contract or union agreement, an employee may be terminated for any non-discriminatory or non-illegal reason, at any time. This may be with or without notice and with or without just cause (though it should be acknowledged that there are variations according to state law).
This principle of ‘at will’ employment is relatively unusual, internationally. In most countries, employment contracts are required, and termination is for ‘just cause’ only, as specified in legislation. This difference can sometimes trip up US organizations that are expanding abroad.
In this article we look at how employee termination or ‘dismissal’ is regulated in key Asia-Pacific countries: China, Singapore, India, and Australia. Just as you should ensure compliance with Equal Employment Opportunities laws in different countries, we recommend you seek professional advice on the termination or dismissal rules in the country you seek to expand into. This needs to be a key part of your global compliance strategy.
Employee Termination in China
Generally speaking, China has stronger employee protections than the United States. The grounds under which an employee may be terminated are clearly set out in the Labor Contract Law of the People’s Republic of China. The key article is article 39 which states an employer may terminate an employee where:
- It can be proven that the employee does not satisfy the job requirements, during the probation period;
- There is a serious violation of the bylaws of the employer;
- The individual causes severe damage to the employer, due to grave neglect of duty or seeking private benefits;
- The individual established a labor relationship with another employer at the same time which has seriously influenced the ability of the employee to complete work, or refuses to make corrections;
- The labor contract is invalidated;
- The individual has criminally offended.
In addition, under article 40, employees can be terminated with notice or compensation where they:
- Are unable to continue with their employment due to being ill or injured;
- Are incapable of doing their job, even after training, and cannot be re-assigned;
- The objective circumstances underlying the contract (I.e. the requirements and circumstances of the employer) have changed.
Employee Termination in Singapore
- The employee is still on their probation period (usually the first 3-6 months of employment);
- The employee breached their contract;
- Employee misconduct;
- Grounds unrelated to misconduct (such as consistent poor job performance or sickness). Note, when terminating on these grounds, warnings and notice must be given;
- Employee transfer;
- Retrenchment (where the position is or is likely to become redundant).
If an employee considers that they have been wrongfully dismissed, they may file a claim with the ‘Tripartite Alliance for Dispute Management’ within one month of dismissal. Where the dismissal was without notice, the obligation is on the employer to prove that the dismissal was wrongful: Where the dismissal was with notice, the employee must themselves prove that the dismissal was wrongful.
Where a claim is not resolved there, it can be taken to the Employment Claims Tribunal who may order reinstatement, payment for loss of income and/or compensation.
Employee Termination in India
In India, employment laws which set out when an employee may be terminated, are set out in both federal and state/union territory laws. This means that the law will differ depending on where employees are based within India. Note that even when an employment contract sets out a process for termination, this is overridden by any requirements set out in statute.
Despite the regional variations, we can state that there are three general ways in which an employer might terminate an employee in India:
- Termination for misconduct or a related cause. This might include wilful disobedience, theft, fraud, dishonesty, absence without leave and negligence at work;
- Termination without cause (but with notice). This allows an employee to be terminated ‘without cause’, as long as they are given 30 days’ notice in writing. Note, that this ground can still be challenged in court so is not without its complications. Laws which capture this requirement include the Delhi Shops and Establishments Act 1954 and associated rules (Delhi Union Territory), and the Maharashtra Shops and Establishments Act 2017 (Maharashtra state);
- Redundancy. Where the individual has been employed for more than two years and their job has become redundant, they will usually be eligible for a severance package to be calculated on a case-by-case basis.
Employee Termination in Australia
The foundation of Australia’s employment law is the Fair Work Act 2009 which applies across Australia. Contained within that is the National Employment Standards (NES) which specify 10 minimum entitlements applying to all employees. In addition, depending on the industry, employees are covered by ‘Modern Awards’, which are a set of minimum conditions that apply only in relation to that industry.
Under the Fair Work Act 2009, an employer may only terminate employment where there is a good reason to do so. That may include:
- Poor job performance;
- Changes to operational requirements in the business.
Termination should be with notice, and employees should have received warnings beforehand. In addition, a fair termination process must be followed. In cases of serious misconduct, an employee can be dismissed without notice.
Employees have rights to challenge any termination with a Commonwealth agency called the Fair Work Commission.
Breaching the laws related to employee termination presents a serious risk for any business in its international expansion. It presents compliance risks (including significant financial penalties from regulators), potential reputational risks (i.e., making it more difficult to recruit top talent in that country), as well as the risk of being sued by an employee.
In order to avoid these risks, it is crucial that you consider how you will ensure compliance with employment laws when expanding into another country. One possible solution is to use the services of a global ‘Professional Employment Organization’ or ‘PEO’, who employs the individual for you while they work for your business.
New Horizons Global Partners provides global PEO, international payroll and human resources solutions, with a focus on the Asia-Pacific region, ensuring that staff are hired and dismissed in full compliance with the laws that operate in that region.